We are getting to the point in Growing Pains where I have pretty high recall for episode plots, and I have to tell you that this episode used to be one of my favourites!
To kick us off, Mike wants to borrow gas money but he gets a big fat no because Maggie and Jason cannot at all trust that he’s going to use the money for what he says it’s for. On the other hand, Carol just wants to go to the library to study and they offer to let her take the car and hand her gas money “just in case”. Mike is aghast. Carol is high and mighty. This is the current Seaver family dynamic, in which we see the great divide between Maggie and Jason’s trust in Carol vs. Mike, and which we will watch slowly erode over the course of this episode.
With money and trust in hand, Carol heads off to the college library where she encounters Matthew Perry, pre-Friends, playing the part of Sandy. Sandy goes to Alf Landon college, which is why he’s studying at the college library and why he assumes Carol’s also a college student. We all know Carol is still a Dewey High Hooter but, not wanting to be seen as too young for him, she tells Sandy she goes to NYU. Sandy invites Carol out for a beer and she can’t resist the charm he’s displayed during their (maybe) two minute conversation, so she agrees to go out with him right then and there. Underage drinking. Claiming she’s a college student. The lies are already starting to pile up for Carol.
And they’re about to pile up even higher, because Carol’s impromptu date with Sandy keeps her out way beyond her curfew, and she got a speeding ticket on the way home. How will she explain all this? Carol knows Maggie and Jason are going to freak out, so she heads straight to Mike’s apartment to get his advice on how to handle the situation. Mike off-handedly tells Carol it doesn’t matter what she tells Maggie and Jason because they’ll believe anything she says. Like, for instance, she could tell them she’s late because of a herd of cattle and they’d buy it hook, line and sinker.
Carol thinks this is preposterous and plans to tell her parents the truth, but then panics the second they start questioning her. She blurts out the first excuse that comes to mind which is, you guessed it, that she got caught on the highway when a herd of cattle got loose. Mike was right, because they buy it! Ah, how simple things could be before the age of the internet and smart phones. Maggie and Jason’s trust in Carol knows no bounds…for now.
The only problem is that Carol’s web of lies means that she has to sneak around to see Sandy again. In fact, the very next day she calls Sandy and invites him over later that evening because her parents will be out. Sneaky, Carol. Very sneaky. She even dodges a major bullet when she leaves the beer bar napkin with Sandy’s number on it right by the phone. Jason assumes it’s Mike who’s hanging out at bars and meeting girls named Sandy. You have to love how a good genderless name can lead to such assumptions. Does Carol think to cut her losses when she realizes she narrowly escaped getting caught? Nope. She keeps on scheming and lying like a champ.
When Sandy arrives, Carol decides all the lying is worth it, and things are getting pretty hot and heavy between the two of them when they’re interrupted by the sound of Maggie and Jason outside. They’re home early! As it turns out, Jason’s car broke down so Carol and Sandy’s night is over and also she needs to get Sandy out of there ASAP. Carol ushers Sandy into the kitchen, and Sandy of course does not at all understand what the big deal is that her parents are home so Carol has to lie yet again. She tells Sandy her dad is a psycho with a gun, and you better bet that gets Sandy moving faster. You’d think Carol would be a bit more concerned that Sandy might never want to see her again because who wants to date a girl with a crazy dad, but I guess getting caught was a much more pressing issue for Carol at the time.
Try as they might, Sandy can’t seem to actually escape from the house. He’s trapped under the kitchen island while Jason rants and raves about the mechanic that tried to pull the wool over his eyes, and at this point he legit sounds and looks a little bit crazy. Sandy appears to be genuinely concerned for his safety, and Carol’s trying to do everything in her power to get her parents out of the kitchen before they see Sandy. But it’s too late. When Jason bends over to pick something up, he sees Sandy and freaks out, then Sandy freaks out and high tails it out the door. Carol’s about to be in a world of trouble, and also it seems highly unlikely that Sandy will ever see her again. After that type of experience, I wouldn’t blame him.
In the wake of all these lies, Carol gets grounded for a solid three weeks. She’s complaining to Mike about it and he aptly points out that it sounds fair because she was the one kid Maggie and Jason could trust, so breaking that trust is a really, really big deal. Carol hadn’t looked at it that way, and suddenly realizes just how awful it was that she took her parents’ trust for granted, which she promptly tells them and then also tells them that she totally agrees that her three-week grounding is fair. Which no teenager would admit to. Ever.
At the end of this episode, I’m left wondering:
- Where was Julie in this episode? What’s with Growing Pains just dropping storylines completely?
- How long will it take for Sandy to return? If I go by the Bobby Wynette standard, it could be an entire season!



