We’ve got ourselves another Ben-centric episode and I remember this one vividly, but I definitely won’t spoil it for you right off the top. Let’s get to it!
The start of this episode is just too much for this child of the 80s, because Ben and Mike are dancing to MTV music videos, and I can remember when people used to actually watch MTV for the music and videos. To add to the vintage feel of this scene, Carol is trying to talk on the phone in the same room and needs them to be quiet because she’s tethered by a corded phone. Guys, do you remember when phones had cords?!?! Do you remember not being able to go wherever you wanted to go with your phone? I sure do.
None of this has anything to do with the story, though, so I’ll get back on track. What we learn is we’re rapidly approaching Jason’s birthday, and Jason is apparently both a birthday fanatic and someone who wants (perhaps expects?) to receive lavish gifts from his family. In fact, he’s doubling down on the kids’ allowances just to make sure that happens.
The kids, of course, are now stressing because they want to get their dad great gifts, although mostly they want to out-do each other in the gifts department. Ben is particularly bummed because he gets less allowance than his older siblings, and how will he ever be able to compete with their gifts? He raises these concerns with Maggie, who tries to assure him that we don’t show our love through the size of our gifts. While that may be true in actuality, Jason certainly hasn’t created that impression with his birthday exuberance.
Still in his funk, Ben stumbles upon some divine intervention—quite literally. As he’s flipping through channels he comes across some sort of evangelical broadcast promoting the power of prayer. Well, Ben’s never tried simply praying for more money so that he can buy his dad a better gift, so there’s no time like the present to start. Ben says a quick prayer to God and no sooner are the words out of his mouth then the doorbell rings.
There, standing on the other side of the door, is a delightful old lady holding out a bucket full of money. Ben, being nine years of age, assumes that she’s giving him the money in response to his prayer. He grabs the money, slams the door in the bewildered lady’s face, and is an instant believer in the Lord’s divine intervention.
Except, of course, the lady isn’t giving Ben money, she’s collecting money for charity and she’s not leaving without her bucket of cash. Within minutes, the matter is all sorted, she gets her money back, admonishes Ben, and leaves him empty-handed all over again.
Ben is crushed. God didn’t actually answer his prayers and he’s still broke. That might’ve been the end of Ben’s efforts to make fast cash if it hadn’t been for Mike. Mike, who had witnessed the entire scenario at the door, jokingly tells Ben that “with his pathetic face” he could probably make a fortune collecting money door to door. Mike is obviously not suggesting that Ben actually do this, but the problem is that 9 year-olds don’t always understand the difference between dry sarcasm and serious suggestions. Mike has inadvertently made a light bulb go off in Ben’s head: what if he did go to door to door collecting money for charity, only that charity is really “Help Me Buy a Gift for My Dad”. I sense trouble.
We jump ahead to Jason’s birthday and it’s time to open his gifts! So far, Jason is really cleaning up in the gifts department. Carol gives him off broadway tickets. Maggie gives him a fishing rod even though we’ve never heard Jason talk about fishing (nor, from my recollection, do we ever see any future signs that Jason is at all outdoorsy). Mike gives him a pretty snazzy set of records, which totally makes sense because we do know Jason loves his music. But Ben is about to blow those gifts out of the water because he’s giving Jason an ultra-fancy camera. Say what!?!
At first Jason is super pumped and thinks nothing of it, because he assumes that Maggie was really behind it. But when she clarifies that she wasn’t, the mood in the room takes a turn. Of course, they ask where Ben got that kind of money (a cool $300 apparently) and he very innocently tells them he went door to door collecting money for the needy because Mike suggested it. Way to throw Mike under the bus, Ben. Once again, Carol is the only child who isn’t implicated in a Seaver family drama.
Jason’s birthday celebration now turns into Jason trying to understand 1) how Ben didn’t know this was wrong and 2) how Ben got the impression that the size and cost of the birthday gift was what mattered. While we don’t know the answer to the first question, I think we all know precisely why Ben thought the gift itself mattered, and that reason is Jason implicitly told his kids the gifts mattered. No matter, it’s time to dole out Ben’s punishment, while simultaneously ensuring he learns his lesson. Poor Ben is going to have to go door to door, giving back the money he took and explaining that he lied to get it. That’s a tough way to learn a lesson. Fair but tough.
At the end of a long day of fessing up to his crimes, Ben finally gives his dad his original gift—a homemade ashtray that looks remarkably like a human heart. Jason is touched, even though he doesn’t smoke, because the gift is from the heart (which I’m just realizing as I write this is maybe why it looks like a human heart???) and that’s what’s most important. Ben also confirms the lesson he has learned through all of this which is that “If God gives [him] an idea, [he’ll] check with [Jason] first.” Jason, I think you might need to do some follow up on this one…
Oh and in case you’re wondering, Mike didn’t escape scot-free. He’s got to donate his next month’s allowance to charity. Even though I still don’t really get how any of this is Mike’s fault, I am always okay with charities receiving more money so this punishment is ultimately for the best. With that, we bring this episode and Jason’s birthday extravaganza to a close, and what an extravaganza it’s truly been!
At the end of this episode, I’m left wondering:
- How did Ben raise $300 in a day? Did people of the 80s have more cash in their pockets and were they more generous with door to door charity collections?
- How did Ben get to the store to buy the camera, get it home and wrap it with no one noticing or asking him what he got for his dad?
- Seriously, why did Mike get punished for this at all? Maggie claims it’s not fair for Mike to even joke with his brother because Ben idolizes him and will do whatever he says, but that’s what siblings do so her ask seems highly unreasonable.